It was a short video. A person wrapped in a blanket was curled up on the ground and a man in a business suit--let's call him Boots--gave him a sharp kick as he walked by. The characters as costumed were a little too dead-on for good fiction, but this was not fiction. It was horrible.
So was the second commenter in the thread. "While I would never do such a thing," he began ominously, "we should realize that a lot of people in this country are pretty fed up with the homeless camps and slackers with their filth and feces and..." It went on. It became clear that the commenter would dearly love to kick the man too, but would settle for fantasizing about it.
I also am appalled at the filth and feces and campsites and begging and everything else that we're seeing so much more of these days. I hate it. I'd rather it weren't there. What I can't fathom is how a person can walk by these tragedies and not ponder that old saw about the grace of God, who is notoriously arbitrary with his blessings. How does someone come to this circumstance?
Boots and his apologists do not, apparently, give it much thought. They do not like the way this human refuse looks or makes them feel, and have already concluded that these people are fundamentally different from them. Maybe not quite human at all. In their charitable moments, they might suppose they're mentally ill, and hope someone will scoop them up and stash them somewhere. Otherwise, it's their fault.
They are not like us. Because we are moral, principled, and hard-working.
We never say "lucky."
One of the problems with imagining the worst of our fellow humans who are homeless is that we then have to believe something happened to suddenly make a huge number of people shiftless or evil, because we haven't seen poverty this widespread in our lifetimes. Assuming that the percentage of mentally ill people remains steady over time, what could have turned so many people so wretched so fast?
Here's where we really get creative. It must be because there's been a moral breakdown since the advent of birth control. Or since we took God out of our schools. Or since the liberals quit teaching their children the difference between right and wrong. Or maybe God is punishing us for gay rights and abortion. Or maybe this is all part of the plan to hurry along the second coming. Something catastrophic, surely, has happened to our society, something we righteous folk had the good sense and fortitude to avoid. One thing we know: that could never be us down there on that sidewalk.
After all, there's no excuse for it, when the economy is doing so well! Unemployment is way down. The market is way up.
I have to say this in a whisper, because the cheerleaders for the current regime spook so easily: all this shit you deplore is a really big sign the economy is not doing well at all. Because you're right: we didn't see this stuff when we were growing up. The economy first started picking the big winners and big losers when Reagan came into power, and cut regulations, and cut taxes on the rich, and privatized for profit what had been in the public trust; and the gap between those who have everything and those who have nothing has widened ever since.
But we the people are the government, here. We can design any economy we want. We can structure our tax system so we reduce or eliminate poverty and strengthen the middle class. Or we can daydream that we'll all be better off if there were no constraints on capitalism, no rules to make sure the least among us could live in dignity, no regulation to preserve our environment and climate. We could make sure that a person working full-time can afford to shelter and feed herself, however modestly, or we could continue to blame hard-working poor people for failing to find better jobs. Right now, we want someone mopping our floors, and cooking our burgers, and picking our lettuce, but we don't think they should be able to support themselves doing it. We really don't value work at all. We value money, stacked high, however obtained.
Extreme capitalism, dedicated solely to profit for shareholders, will always produce more billionaires and more people we want to kick. Always. It's up to us to insist on a better world. If you're offended by beggars and camps and filth everywhere you look, quit voting for the billionaire party. And if you don't want immigrants and refugees either, quit voting for the warmongers and climate destroyers. It's a direct damn line.
Contraction
10 hours ago
Empathy and understanding are traits that have been downplayed by the kickers for quite some time now. I agree that it mostly started with Ronald Raygun and the systematic deterioration to where we are now. Will it get worse or will things be different after the revolution?
ReplyDeleteI'm discouraged most of the time, except when I don't think about it. When the billionaires got hold of the propaganda machine they really started to rack up the damage. Until they figured out how to present their case, no one would have voted for it.
DeleteIf everyone could just get off their asses and vote...
ReplyDelete...and be allowed to vote...
DeleteAmen, sister. Great post. So many of us out here in the more rural areas don't connect the rampant meth use, the small hospitals being overwhelmed with either drug/alcohol use, and the paucity of decent jobs with the party they vote for, time after time. Instead, they decry the cities, say it's because they are sanctuary sities, because they are 'liberal', etc.
ReplyDeleteKeep it up.
As if I could stop. Thanks!
DeleteI was surprised by the performance of Bill de Blasio at the Democratic debate last week. He was emphatic. Soeaking of the separation of families at the border, he said, “Those are not our values, but we have to get under the skin of why we have this crisis in our system, because we’re not being honest about the division that’s been fomented in this country, the way that Americans citizens have been told that [insert sub group]somehow created their misery and their pain and their challenges,” the mayor said.
ReplyDelete“For all the American citizens out there who feel you’re falling behind or feel the American dream’s not working for you, the [sub group]didn’t do that to you. The big corporations did that to you. The one percent did that to you,” he said.
Amen.
DeleteI thought he was terrific. I guess I don't follow the news slavishly, because a lot of the candidates were new to me. Some were very impressive.
DeleteIf only that one percent could live a year in our shoes.
DeleteOr, in whatever shoes they give you in jail. Whichever. There's no morality in being a billionaire. I love AOC's comment: Every billionaire is a policy failure.
DeleteThere is something extremely wrong when college kids graduate and they can't find jobs to sustain themselves. More and more kids are living with parents because they can't afford rent, utilities on income from flipping burgers (the only jobs to be had after graduation). Yes, why, why, why do people vote for billionaire party? These billionaires are so far removed from poverty they don't see it...so they trash our environment and fail to see the poverty stricken and they don't pay taxes.
ReplyDeleteBTW do you think those republicans who walked out to avoid voting on a bill will be re-elected in Oregon? I hope not.
DeleteWell, they've got the militia vote. I don't know how big that is.
DeleteIt IS a direct line, but somehow a great many people can't see it. Kool-Aid, they've drunk it.
ReplyDeleteThey have been misinformed and misdirected and have not learned critical thinking. Sheep to be fleeced.
DeleteI stop in at a homeless support centre often. The staff maxim is that many of us are only an unexpected crisis (job loss/divorce/illness) away from life on the street. They treat everyone with dignity and respect which is one of the reasons I support them.
ReplyDeleteYet another great post Murr.
You make me proud to "know" you, and I think we do know each other by now, right?
DeleteI keep wanting to hit “like” on so many of these comments, but alas blogs do not have that feature. As always, spot on sistah!
ReplyDeleteHa! It's probably for the best.
DeleteWe are seeing a sad increase in this country.Note the word "increase." And in a week that saw more devastating cuts, politicians just gave themselves ANOTHER increase.
ReplyDeleteI know to which backsides I'd like to apply my boot.
The bigger they are, the more likely your boot will get stuck.
DeleteSpot on! This one needs to go to the NYT.
ReplyDeleteThanks, but I'll probably skip it. I think they prefer things a little less general.
DeleteI think today's societal worship of wealth and insatiable quest for more, more, more is expressed well by Pierre Boiste's quote: "The heart of a greedy man is an ocean, waiting for the rain."
ReplyDeleteOh, that's super!
DeleteI fear the widening gap between the All or Nothing is worldwide and I know for sure not all the homeless are the mentally ill cast-outs. Last year one of my own was homeless, sleeping rough, and I didn't know about it until one rainy night when he came knocking and asked to spread his sleeping bag on the floor. He did this for the rest of the winter while I helped out with hot meals and showers so he could save enough to get into a share house.
ReplyDeleteThe tents are one thing; the number of people fogging windshields at the curb, all year, is another.
DeleteGreat post, Murr. Keep it up: as if you couldn't ... ;-)
ReplyDeleteYou got me pegged.
Delete